Library Tutorial for Legal 100

In this unit, you will learn how to evaluate the sources you find on the web.  Read the material and watch the videos - and don't forget to take notes for the quiz.

Now that we know about how search results are generated, we can start to think about how to sift through our search results and choose relevant and credible sources from our results lists. Evaluating sources is a critical skill that you need in your academic life, as well as your professional and personal life.  At every stage, you want to ensure that the information you find is valid and trustworthy. 

1. WATCH: 2 minute video from EdCC Library about the ASAP method of evaluation.

2. PRACTICE: Use the ASAP method to evaluate these two websites. Take notes about what you can find out about the Authority, Sources, Age, and Purpose of each site. 

• Nutrition Source
• Calorie Control Council

While Wikipedia has a lot of information that many find useful, we know anyone can edit Wikipedia articles.  The library has several other valuable resources such as ebooks, encyclopedias and articles from newspapers, magazines, and journals.  Many instructors will not allow Wikipedia to be used in academic research and Wikipedia has its own cautions about using its information for research. 

Wikipedia’s own statement states that:

• It is not a reliable source for research. 
• Not everything in Wikipedia is accurate, comprehensive, or unbiased.
• Anyone may edit an article, deleting accurate information or adding false information.

If you must use Wikipedia to find the information you are seeking, use it only for background, overview information and evaluate the information by doing the following: 

• Use the A. S. A. P. Evaluation 
• Checked the sources listed at the end of the article to see if they are credible. 
• Check the Talk section of the article to see the discussion among the editors who contributed to the article.
• Compare the arguments and evidence from the article with information from other credible sources to verify its accuracy. 

False news (aka "Fake News") refers to misinformation that is intentionally passed off as credible news.  This may include factual errors, misrepresentations of facts, omissions, and biases, along with a lack of verifiable evidence and facts to support the claims.

The purpose of this news information is often to persuade you toward a particular viewpoint, but it may also be to persuade you to keep clicking to generate ads, or even to entertain you, or scam you into giving out your personal information.

Watch the video below to learn how to spot  this type of news.

While there has been a tremendous rise in false news information, there has also been a rise in the number of organizations and businesses dedicated to fact-checking it.

Below are two examples of non-profit resources you can use to check the facts presented in the news information you receive (and yes, you can also evaluate these resources using the C. R. A. P. Test).

Verifying Facts:

FactCheck.org
"Nonpartisan, nonprofit 'consumer advocate' for voters that aims to reduce the level of deception and confusion in U.S. politics.

Verify Webpage History:
Wayback Machine
Non-profit "digital library of Internet sites" that saves websites  and can be used to find history and old content of websites. 

  Finally...

Evaluating websites can be a difficult process, even with the tools and skills you have learned in this lesson.  If you are still not sure whether your source is credible, be sure to ask a librarian.

Next, go to Unit 9 to learn how to ethically use the sources you want to use in your research and Avoid Plagiarism.